Sunday Classics preview: Can you identify the composer(s)?
>

We have here two versions of the same little waltz, one for solo piano, the other for string quartet. Obviously one is an arrangement of the other, though not necessarily by the original composer. Your challenge is to guess the composer of the original version -- who, in case you hadn't guessed, is the subject of this week's Sunday Classics. Of course, you should also identify which version is the original.
For extra credit, identify the composer of the arranged version.
Here is the piano version:

8 Comments:
Schubert's the original, I think. No idea on the arrangement, but you know, it might be interesting to figure out just how many composers have arranged Schubert over the years. Even if you leave out the endless March Millitaires, it's a large number, with some unlikely candidates that include Liszt and Schoenberg.
Of course, if I'm wrong, carry on. :D
My guess is that the original version is the piano version. I would think that whoever the composer is would write a larger work for the strings, but short piano pieces are always in abundance for a composer who used the piano.
weird but I also get a smetana or Dvorak feeling from this.
By the way, it's in A Major!
OK...I say DVORAK!!
oops sorry, for some reason they changed my name...ohnoooo! is also mimi...
Hmm, some interesting thinking going on here. I have a feeling you'll have it nailed with tonight's additional clues.
Ken
Sorry, I got mixed up...the first note is an A, the piece is in D Major!
(sorry, didn't mean to throw people off track)
Mimi
ack...ignore me...
Yeah, it's not Schubert. It's Dvorak or Smetana, as ohnooo stated. I'm thinking Smetana. It's the harmonic progression in the bass line that makes me think that.
Post a Comment
<< Home