Thursday, December 22, 2016

Will The Real Tulsi Gabbard Please Stand Up... Please Stand Up

>


Long before her sudden transformation into a Berniecrat, Tulsi Gabbard called me to ask for a Blue America endorsement. She didn't really try to paint herself as a progressive and she came across as a garden variety careerist Democrat, not especially bad and not especially good. At the end of the interview, I asked her about the process by which she had come to change her position on LGBT equality. She immediately said she'd call back and then hung up abruptly and... never called back.

She's extremely popular in Hawaii, where people have largely bought into her self-promoting brand of vaguely anti-establishment nationalism. These days she likes to claim she's a progressive and it is widely thought she will primary Senator Mazie Hirono from the left. ProgressivePunch rates Mazie a high "A," the third best of any U.S. Senator 96.39, fractionally behind Elizabeth Warren's 96.97 and a bit ahead of Bernie's 94.99. There isn't any room to the left of Mazie-- especially not from the sleazy Tulsi Gabbard who's lifetime crucial vote score has earned her score of 73.75 and an "F" rating. Many Democrats with F ratings use their district's conservatism as the excuse. Problem with that is that Tulsi represents one of the most progressive districts in the whole country, with a PVI of D+21. Obama beat Romney there, 71-27%. The only grief Tulsi Gabbard would get if she had a progressive voting record would be from her ultra-conservative family, her Republican financial backers and her enablers at Fox News-- oh, and her pal Steve Bannon.

To help explain the Tulsi Gabbard phenomenon, I reached out to an old friend on the Big Island-- part of Tulsi's district-- who follows politics closely and has a very long memory. This is his report on one aspect of Tulsi's record, her long-running homophobia:
We need to flee from the hollow wooden statue of a Progressive in which Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard has concealed herself to enter Washington. One can get whiplash following Tulsi Gabbard as she darts to and fro from far Left and far Right. She continues to confuse Bernie devotees, aggressive in her lack of sympathy toward Syrian refugees and then bold in her support of the Lakota Sioux against Big Oil. There is nothing inherently wrong about being an effective national politician determined to break free of political genre. A survey of Tulsi’s political record makes clear, however, that she is a populist without principle.

To make sense of Tulsi’s pendular politics, it is time that we look to the locals intimate with the Woman of Hawaii. The most informative criticisms of late come from Hawaii residents who have dredged into Tulsi’s past and brought up more filth than gold.

In Hawaii, Tulsi earned a reputation among her former colleagues in the State Legislature as one of their most bigoted contemporaries. She defined her local career as an outspoken anti-gay and anti-reproductive rights politician. Volumes of official records from the Hawaii State Legislative Reference Bureau tell Tulsi’s story in her own words. Here, Tulsi, then Representative Tamayo, presents a floor speech against a measure supported by local hospitals that resolved to study the needs of LGBTQ students, who continue to suffer the highest rates of suicide in the state:




In this same speech, Tulsi is also recorded as describing gay rights advocates as “homosexual extremists.” Tulsi is no grassroots phenom. She represents the state’s main conservative political dynasty, which successfully campaigned to ban same-sex marriage through constitutional amendment. Her father, Senator Mike Gabbard, led the anti-gay movement in the state and also founded Stand Up For America, a non- profit that promoted nationalism through “the concept of how we are one nation under God.”

Tulsi was also defined by her consistent opposition to basic rights for women. Here, Tulsi joins a Republican bloc to oppose emergency contraceptives for rape victims. This was one of several instances where she attempted to restrict reproductive rights for women on the grounds of religious freedom.




Tulsi has since distanced herself from this unsavory record with a heroic tale of transformation. According to Tulsi’s website, in 2004 she volunteered to fight in the Iraq War, which triggered a libertarian awakening. The facts deviate from the straight and narrow narrative. Nearly seven years later, Tulsi still opposed equal rights for LGBTQ people. Evidence such as this newly discovered constituent email prove that for over a decade in and out of public office, and long after her purported “transformation,” Tulsi was still anti-gay.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, February 04, 2019

President Tulsi?

>




An old friend of mine called the other day to say she wanted to congratulate me on the post I wrote exposing Tulsi Gabbard as a fraud a couple of years ago and that she planned to send it around her social media circles. I told her two things, first that I had written dozens of posts exposing Tulsi as a fraud so I was unsure which one she meant and second, that I had had an opportunity to sit down and speak with Tulsi at length recently and that I am less likely to express antipathy towards her and more likely to listen to what she has to say with an open mind. I noted that Pramila Jayapal had just reintroduced the Medicare-For-All bill, and that Tulsi signed on as a co-sponsor immediately (unlike 45 other members of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, who refused to) and that although just 45 members of Congress had committed to the Green New Deal, Tulsi was one of the very first AND that when I was beating the bushes to find some brave souls to join AOC and Ro Khanna in opposing the virulently anti-progressive PAY-GO scam, the only person I persuaded to do so was Tulsi.

That doesn't mean I'm going to vote for her to be president-- nor did it keep me from publishing a guest post from state Senator Kai Kahele, who is challenging her to a primary for her seat while she runs for president.

Over the weekend, Tulsi launched her presidential campaign with a full-blown progressive wish-list. She was raised, I'm told, to believe she would one day be president. She seems like a long-shot now but... you have to start somewhere. She's starting by going hard after the foreign policy establishment, long her main area of interest. "We must stand united and stand strong against those in both parties who never tire of war-- neocons and neolibs who drag us from one regime-change war to the next and who are exacerbating the new Cold War, pushing us to the brink of nuclear war... We must stand against powerful politicians from both parties who sit in ivory towers thinking up new wars to wage & new places for people to die. Wasting trillions of dollars, hundreds of thousands of lives, undermining our economy and security, and destroying our middle class... These powerful politicians dishonor the sacrifices made by every one of our service members, and their families-- they are the ones who pay the price for these wars."

Even before she announced, corporate media was on the attack, accusing her of being the Russian tool in the cycle. Robert Windrem and Ben Popken wrote for NBC News that "the Russian propaganda machine that tried to influence the 2016 U.S. election is now promoting the presidential aspirations of a controversial Hawaii Democrat who earlier this month declared her intention to run for president in 2020" and reporting that "an NBC News analysis of the main English-language news sites employed by Russia in its 2016 election meddling shows Gabbard... has become a favorite of the sites Moscow used when it interfered in 2016... RT, the Russian-owned TV outlet; Sputnik News, a radio outlet; and Russia Insider, a blog that experts say closely follows the Kremlin line."
All three sites celebrated Gabbard's announcement, defended her positions on Russia and her 2017 meeting with Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad, and attacked those who have suggested she is a pawn for Moscow. The coverage devoted to Gabbard, both in news and commentary, exceeds that afforded to any of the declared or rumored Democratic candidates despite Gabbard's lack of voter recognition.

Gabbard was mentioned on the three sites about twice as often as two of the best known Democratic possibilities for 2020, Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders, each with 10 stories. Kamala Harris and Elizabeth Warren had fewer. In each case, the other contenders were treated more critically than Gabbard... "Her promulgation of positions compatible with Russian geo strategic interests can help them mainstream such discussion in the [Democratic] party," said Alex Stamos, former chief security officer at Facebook and now an NBC News analyst. Gabbard, said Stamos, helps them with all their "lines of attack."

...Gabbard's most controversial position and the one where she's most in line with Russian interests is on Syria. She's accused the U.S. of pushing a policy of "regime change" wars and in January 2017, she met with Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad in Syria on what she called a "fact-finding mission."

RT began defending Gabbard as soon as she announced. A behavioral science expert who studies social media tweeted out a vow on Jan. 11 to start a GoFundMe campaign to finance a reporting trip to Gabbard's Hawaii district. Reporters for RT's television network pounced, calling it "an investigative vacation" and a "beachside investigation" by an "establishment Democrat."

On Jan. 12, the day after Gabbard announced, RT headlined her decision this way: "'Putin puppet' vs 'Assad shill': Dems & Reps unite in panic over Gabbard challenging Trump in 2020."

The unsigned article claimed, "With Representative Tulsi Gabbard (D-Hawaii) entering the 2020 presidential fray, establishment figures on both Right and Left are scrambling to smear the anti-war congresswoman with impeccable identity-politics bona fides. Ever since her 2017 visit to Syria, Gabbard has been condemned for daring to seek firsthand accounts rather than blindly trusting the MSM narrative, so on Friday the pundits were again off to the races, with fresh accusations of Assad-sympathizing."

On Jan. 16, Lee Stranahan, one of the co-hosts on Fault Line, a Washington-based program on Sputnik News, admitted that the debates should be the focus for Gabbard.

"The significant thing about her being in the race is because one of her main issues is peace and specifically on Syria, where she is telling the truth on Syria," said Stranahan, who joined Sputnik after stints at Breitbart News, the right-wing news site. "I think she is going to change the debate. If she can get through the first few months, and make it to actual debates, is there a big millionaire or billionaire that will support Tulsi Gabbard."

The same day, conservative writer Hunter Derensis noted on Russia Insider, "In line with her thinking on Syria, she lacks the anti-Russian stance of other Democratic politicians. 'How does going to war with Russia over Syria serve the interest of the American people?' she mentioned in a tweet. Gabbard has also supported Trump's diplomatic summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un in one of her multiple appearances with Tucker Carlson."

That story was headlined, "Heroic Tulsi Gabbard Will Run on Her Sensible Foreign Policy. Expect Democrats, Faux Progressives to Squeal."

In articles on the Russian sites, Gabbard is described as a "rebel," who is "straight-talking" and a "heroic" candidate who will "shake up" the establishment.

Coverage of other Democratic presidential hopefuls in pro-Kremlin media has been for the most part perfunctory, limited to candidates' announcements or summaries of their relative prospects. In recent weeks, Sputnik has poked fun at Elizabeth Warren's beer commercial and a widely circulated photo of Beto O'Rourke's in a dentist chair.

Erika Tsuji, a spokeswoman for Gabbard, said it as "ridiculous" to suggest the Russians supported her candidacy.

"Russia would never overtly support a candidate they wanted to help, because it would just hurt their candidacy," said Tsuji. "It’s common sense."

Tsuji also said that "From the start, Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard has denounced Russia's attempts to muddle (sic) in our elections and will continue to do so." She noted that Gabbard had cosponsored legislation calling for an independent investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election, cosponsored a bill prohibiting foreign influence in the election process, and sponsored a bill to protect election infrastructure from hackers.

Experts in Russian on-line propaganda say Gabbard appeals to pro-Russian sites because her positions —and her appeal as an outsider in her own party — can be used to create division among Democrats.

Former FBI agent Clint Watts, author of Messing with the Enemy: Surviving in a Social Media World of Hackers, Terrorists, Russians, and Fake News, said Gabbard has past or present positions on several issues that would be attractive to the Russian propaganda machine, and she is already popular with the U.S. "alt-left." Besides her views on Syria, she responded to reports of Russian interference in the 2016 election by saying the U.S. had interfered in foreign elections too.

...Watts and Stamos think the Russians may be gravitating to Gabbard not because they think she can win, but because her positions, often in line with those of the Kremlin, will become part of the Democratic primary debates.

"They probably just spotted her and figured this is someone to promote," said Watts, who is also an NBC News analyst. "You can just see it coming. They're telegraphing what coming the next two years, which is playing in the left."

"They want someone like Gabbard to voice a Russian position. They are not telling her what to say but they want her pro-Russian positions play into the debate."

Stamos agrees that Gabbard could be used to inject pro-Russian positions into the Democratic Party's discussions and debates during primary season.

"We should expect the Russian intel services and troll farms to be active in the Democratic primary process," said Stamos, "as this provides them with the best opportunity to create the most division in American society in 2020."
In the weeks before her "informal" announcement of candidacy on CNN and Saturday's "official" announcement, all three of Hawaii’s most influential columnists hadwritten anti-Tulsi pieces. That's unusual for Hawaii. Lee Cataluna, from the Honolulu Star-Advertiser is the most influential and his column Despite masking, Gabbard’s words remainwas devastating. He wrote that Tulsi has "a past full of gaping holes, hateful words and bigoted intentions that she fully expects people to ignore... Like other politicians and celebrities of our time, Gabbard is an expert in curating her image. Her public self is softened by filters. There’s lots of stuff edited or cropped out. Gabbard can try to brush away hateful things she said about LGBT people in her not-so-long-ago youth, but the unedited truth is that she didn’t just slip and say a bad word, she actively, passionately worked against the legalization of same-sex marriage. She belonged to a group of rabid advocates of 'traditional' marriage. She went to meetings, she strategized, she participated, she took action. She didn’t just drink the Kool-Aid served by her LGBT-hating parents; she helped them make the juice... Nobody takes her as seriously as she takes herself. Her intended climb is precipitous, and the baggage she carries is heavy, laden with a history of organized, strategized homophobia. She says she’s changed. She’ll say whatever she needs to say."



Covering Kirsten Gillibrand's announcement that she was running for president, CNN correspondent Dan Merica quoted Gillibrand's response to "questions about her policy shifts 10 years ago when she moved from the House to the Senate." Gillibrand has been telling the media this:
"I think it is important to know when you are wrong and to do what is right."
At that point-- this point-- it's up to each voter to determine if Gillibrand's statement is sincere, authentic and believable. I am certain that it isn't. She may have changed her mind that xenophobia doesn't best serve her career opportunities as well as it did when she was the poster child for New York's anti-immigrant campaign and she may have changed her mind that being the New York State poster child for the NRA doesn't best serve her career opportunities as well as it did when she represented a rural upstate congressional district. But I know her well enough that she never cared about either of these policy agendas. She didn't care about them when she was playing the race card and the gun-nut card and she doesn't care about them when she's pretending to be pro-immigrant and anti-gun. None of this is important to Kirsten Gillibrand. She's another political sociopath that doesn't think beyond herself and her career-- the very worst of what American politics pukes up from time to time. So what about Tulsi? Cataluna seems to have made his mind up. Now the rest of us are going to have to.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, November 23, 2016

So What's Wrong With Tulsi Gabbard? She Was For Bernie, After All

>

Tulsi-- always palin' around with fascists

Collin Peterson, a Minnesota Blue Dog, is, arguably, the most reactionary Democrat in Congress. ProgressivePunch rates him an "F" and his lifetime crucial vote score is a mind-boggling 39.81. It's been even worse lately-- 35.95 in the current session, the 4th worst of any Democrat in the House. Trump won every single one of the 38 counties in Peterson's sprawling western Minnesota district., even the ones Obama won in 2012. Peterson, who had weak and under-funded opposition this cycle barely scraped by with 52.5% of the vote-- 173,571 to 156,950. Dave Hughes, his GOP opponent, had no help from the NRCC and only raised $17,086 to Peterson's $1,125,805, but still came within just a few points of beating him. Peterson has long been in the pocket of corporate AgriBusiness, which has largely funded his career. Peterson, for his own reasons, endorsed Bernie over the much-disliked Hillary. That didn't make Peterson a progressive and not even the dullest minds among the kids whose first experience of politics was joining the Bernie Crusade and falling sway to the cult of personality that grew up around him.

Tulsi Gabbard isn't as bad as Collin Peterson, but ProgressivePunch also grades her an F. We've been covering Gabbard here at DWT since 2011 when she decided to run for Congress. She's from a very right-wing political family best known in Hawaii and gay-hating fanatics who have fought against equality for many years. Before being elected to Congress, she led the opposition to gay marriage equality in the state legislature. She once called me to ask for a Blue America endorsement. When I asked her about her change of heart on LGBT issues-- she claims she isn't anti-gay any longer-- she quickly hung up the phone, claiming she'd call back. I knew she never would of course. A "Fox News Dem, she's always hanging around right-wingers; she dated Republican Mafia Congressman Michael "Mikey Suits" Grimm before he went to prison and she's always around characters like crackpot Schmuley Boteach and genocidal Islamaphobe Narendra Modi. She was long one of Fox's go-to congresswomen when they needed a Democrat to attack Obama.

Some people excuse Peterson's right-wing voting record because his constituents are so right-wing. That isn't an excuse Gabbard can use. She represents one of the bluest districts in America. McCain only scored 25% there. Romney got 27%. The PVI is D+21. Last week Hillary swept every county in the district. On the Big Island, for example, Hillary took 41,258 votes to Trump's 17,500. Her own opponent, Angela Aulani Kaaihue ( a nutty Trump supporter), took only 18.9% of the vote and didn't report raising or spending any money at all. Gabbard spent $1,068,459 of the $2,060,649 she raised. So... her shitty voting record is very different from Peterson's. In fact, of all the Democrats with "F" scores from ProgressivePunch, only one has a bluer district. She has no electoral excuse for voting with the GOP so much.

She clashed with Debbie Wasserman Schultz at the DNC, quit in a big public row and endorsed Bernie, even though their records are not remotely similar. Democrats in Hawaii laughed when Berniebots, grateful for her support but ignorant of her politics, started promoting her as a progressive.

Another pro-Putin lunatic, she was all over the news this week when her pal Steve Bannon arranged for her to meet with Trump, presumably for a job interview.
“He reached out to her, not vice versa,” the source told The Hill on Monday.


Bannon, a navy veteran, was drawn to her when she began publicly excoriating the Obama administration over its plan to defeat ISIS.

“He loves Tulsi Gabbard. Loves her,” a second source familiar with Bannon’s thinking told The Hill. “Wants to work with her on everything.”

“She would fit perfectly too [inside the administration],” the source added. “She gets the foreign policy stuff, the Islamic terrorism stuff.”

Bannon appreciates Gabbard’s willingness to publicly criticize President Obama for refusing to name the enemy, “radical Islamic terrorism.”

“For him it’s a win-win when a Democrat is saying those things,” said a third source, who used to work under Bannon at Breitbart News.
They're considering her for the UN ambassador job something in the security realm (maybe). Yesterday, when all this started bubbling over, Eoin Higgins, writing for Paste, lent her voice to the wakeup call of delusional Berniebots: Tulsi Gabbard is Not Who You Think She Is. Higgins understands just how terrible Gabbard is. "To some progressives," she wrote, "the news Monday that Tulsi Gabbard was meeting with President-Elect Donald Trump for consideration of a position in his administration must have been confusing. Gabbard’s February 2016 endorsement of Bernie Sanders’ quixotic run for the Democratic nomination for president involved publicly resigning her seat as DNC Vice Chair. Her name has been floated as a possible candidate for 2020. And at a glance, her positions seem in line with the liberal wing of her party. But a deeper look at Gabbard’s political career shows that she is devoted to attaining power and to the perpetuation of extremist, fringe ideology. She adopts and sheds extremist positions at will, but one thing remains constant: her consistent embrace of hard-right politics."
The 35-year-old Congresswoman from Hawaii was raised in a politically powerful household. Her father, Mike Gabbard, is a well-known firebrand in Hawaiian politics-- his most beloved issue is a virulent rejection of homosexuality and gay rights.

The younger Gabbard protested against a bill advocating civil unions during her tenure in the Hawaii Congress, holding up signs decrying the proposition. The bill eventually stalled.

Gabbard replied to a request for comment on her father’s connections with cult leader Chris Butler (more below) in 2004 with an oddly worded email accusing Honolulu Magazine of a homosexual conspiratorial attempt to discredit her father.
“I smell a skunk,” [Gabbard] wrote. “It’s clear to me that you’re acting as a conduit for the Honolulu Weekly and other homosexual extremist supporters of Ed Case.”
This political position held until 2012, when she made an about face and declared she supported gay rights-- just in time for the election for Hawaii’s 2nd District. And that wasn’t the first time she had shed a piece of her past in order to make herself more palatable to voters.

Gabbard’s first marriage, to a man named Eduardo Tamayo, lasted from 2002 to 2006. Tamayo and Gabbard were both involved with a man named Chris Butler, the leader of a Hare Krishna spinoff called the Science of Identity Foundation that is located in Honolulu County.

The Hawaii Free Press notes that a number of Butler-connected Hawaiians have contributed to Gabbard and that her involvement with the cult is still an open question.

Gabbard has scrubbed all mention of her past with Butler’s cult, and with Tamayo, from the internet. The only evidence that is publicly available that Tamayo and Gabbard even know each other-- excepting her Wikipedia page-- is from anti-cult site Flashlight on Roaches. It’s grainy, but it does show the two together. It’s also the only known photo of Tamayo that is publicly available.

Today, Gabbard would prefer not to be known for her Butler-cult related past. The only way to find it is to dig deep into Hawaiian-centric newsletters and publications. But for those in Hawaii, it’s an omnipresent part of her political and social history. As the Honolulu Civil Beat reported on March 16, 2015:
The Gabbard family’s ties to Butler still hound her-- in the hallways of the Hawaii State Capitol, on blogs of political observers, on pages of online discussion forums, and in commentary sections of various news sites, including Civil Beat’s.

Now, the mysterious world that’s been swirling around Gabbard all her life is coming under closer scrutiny as the 33-year-old congresswoman’s stature on the national stage steadily rises, and her views on national and international issues-- whether she’s standing up for veterans or challenging President Barack Obama over his stance on the Islamic State-- continue to draw the media spotlight.
By now, Gabbard has left any ambiguity about her religious beliefs behind. She identifies as a member of the Gaudiya Vaishnavism Sect of the Hindu faith.

It’s a faith she shares with India’s leader, Narendra Modi. But they share more than that-- they share a hard-right political philosophy that is at odds with Gabbard’s perceived role as a liberal touchstone in the Democratic Party.

Modi, a member of the Bharatiya Janata Party, or BJP, is well known in India for his hardline right wing politics. He was the governor of the state of Gujarat during riots in 2002 that killed over 2,000 Muslims. Modi has always skirted around his level of responsibility for the violence; on the one hand he can appeal to moderates by claiming ignorance, on the other his claims of ignorance are delivered with winks to the country’s more extremist right-wing elements.

Modi relies on Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, or RSS, for political backing. The BJP and RSS’s actions have been repressive and violent and involve a complete distortion of historical and material reality in order to maintain their control of the state.

The RSS-BJP alliance also uses the fears and prejudices of the majority Hindu Indian population against Muslims to ensure its hold on power. And those views are views that Gabbard shares with them-- despite her framing of herself as a peaceful warrior.

...Gabbard’s relationship with Modi is well documented in Indian publications. Her admiration of the authoritarian leader is the subject of multiple interviews, where she consistently affirms her support of the Prime Minister and his hardline party. In a three-week visit to India on the invitation of Modi himself, she was treated as a state guest and held private meetings with the Prime Minister and members of his party.

And Gabbard has protected Modi’s interests in the US. She fought against a November, 2015, Congressional bill mentioning his role in the Gujarat massacres, decried the US’s refusal to issue a visa for the controversial leader before 2014, and supported efforts to rewrite Indian history from a Hindu-supremacist viewpoint in US textbooks.

She has worked to relax restrictions on Indian immigration to the US even as she joins with Trump’s rhetoric in attempts to refuse allowing Syrian refugees into the country. And her views on Islam mirror those of Modi’s-- both insist that identifying the faith of Islamists is of paramount importance in fighting extremism (not of Hindu extremism, of course).



Gabbard quickly flipped on Donald Trump. When Trump appointed white nationalist Stephen Bannon as his Senior Strategist two weeks ago and 169 Congressional Democrats opposed the move, Gabbard’s name was notably missing.

Perhaps it’s because Gabbard is, once again, jettisoning political beliefs that are no longer useful in her quest for power. It could be that Sanders and the Democrats are no longer helpful to her career, like her father’s homophobia and her public cult-connected marriage. So they must go so Gabbard can continue her rise.

That’s a likely scenario. But it only works if you remember that the other constant in Gabbard’s career is an attraction to hard-right political positions. Even those positions she eventually leaves behind are replaced with more extreme positions-- her anti-gay activism replaced with Islamophobia, her ties to a Hawaiian cult replaced with ties to Hindu extremism.

News media have reported that Gabbard is under consideration for a position with the Trump administration, that her meeting with the president-elect was more than a bipartisan discussion-- it was a job interview.

Given what we know about Gabbard’s attraction to the extreme right and her thirst for power, a place in the Trump administration won’t come as a surprise. It’s par for the course.
Gabbard is at a weird crossroads now. It's been common knowledge in Hawaii that she was preparing to exploit her "Bernie cred" to run against an actual progressive, U.S. Senator Mazie Hirono in 2018. But now she may have a job offer more in line with her own political nature, allowing her to stop pretending to be a progressive. Should be interesting to watch but I'm even more interested in knowing who will replace her in Congress. I'm hoping it will be progressive state Rep. Kaniela Ing of Maui, whose website describes him as "a bold, profeminist, Native Hawaiian progressive who stalwartly fights for economic, social, racial, gender, immigrant, indigenous, and LGBT justice. Ing proudly supports a $15 minimum wage, 16 weeks paid family lave, ending unnecessary wars in the middle east, debt-free college, reducing income inequality, transgendered rights, equal pay, legalizing marijuana, and seeks to restore public trust in government through campaign finance reform, repealing the SCOTUS decisions that created SuperPacs, and clean, open elections." Very different from Tulsi Gabbard-- and a lot more in sync where Bernie Sanders stands on issues.



Labels: , , , ,

Friday, June 09, 2017

Tulsi Gabbard vs The Progressive Caucus

>


For more than a quarter-century, the Congressional Progressive Caucus has been doggedly working to advance liberal policy and opinion in Washington, with success even in times of conservative leadership.

The largest House Democratic caucus, the Progressive Caucus has repeatedly been able to block right-leaning legislation, while working to improve Democrats’ bills and positively influence public discourse.

The 1991 founding of the Congressional Progressive Caucus was a partnership of Bernie Sanders (I-VT), then his first term in the House; Patsy Mink (D-HI), the first woman of color elected to Congress; and several other liberal Members of Congress, including some who still serve in the House, such as Maxine Waters (D-CA) and Peter DeFazio (D-OR).

Meanwhile, the Gabbard family of Hawaii spent the ‘90s moving in another direction, in a tenacious but ultimately unsuccessful fight against marriage equality.

The Chicago Tribune reported on the Gabbards' marriage battle in a 1994 story:
"I think that the whole issue of same-sex marriage comes down to examining the values of family, and society has an interest in keeping families strong. The bedrock of family is marriage," said Mike Gabbard, president of the two main local groups opposing same-sex marriage, Common Sense Now and Stop Promoting Homosexuality Hawaii.

"To me, the whole thing is about acceptance," Gabbard said. "They want homosexual behavior to be accepted on a par with heterosexual behavior."
Mike Gabbard’s daughter Tulsi caught the political bug in early adulthood and was elected to the state legislature in 2002. Mike was also elected to the Honolulu City Council that year. Carol Gabbard (Mike’s wife and Tulsi’s mom) was already an elected member of the state Board of Education. All three Gabbards won their seats with anti-LGBTQ campaign messages. Even in tolerant Hawaii, those kinds of campaigns were effective in those days.

Tulsi’s unremarkable tenure as a young, inexperienced state legislator is remembered mostly for her crusade against anti-bullying efforts:
State Rep. Tulsi Gabbard Tamayo, D-42nd (Waipahu, Honouliuli, 'Ewa), Gabbard's daughter, said the figures released by her mother contradict a claim in the House resolution that gay and lesbian students are three times as likely as other students to face harassment.

Tamayo said a study that asks students questions about their sexuality would be a violation of student privacy. She also said many parents would see the study as an indirect attempt by government to encourage young people to question their sexual orientation.

Gabbard Tamayo said the harassment figures "show that our schools are not rampant with anti-gay harassment."
Tulsi Gabbard (after dropping "Tamayo" following a divorce) won her own seat on the Honolulu City Council, with the endorsement of the Hawaii Rifle Association, in 2010.

But by 2012, she said had shifted leftward and announced she was running for Congress as the progressive alternative to then-frontrunner Mufi Hannemann, whose conservative social views were out of step with the district. Hawaii’s Second Congressional District has never come close to electing a Republican and has previously been represented by Mink and Progressive Caucus member Mazie Hirono, who left the seat in a successful 2012 run for Senate.

Tulsi Gabbard had helped run her Republican father’s vociferously anti-LGBTQ campaign for the seat in 2004. But with newly minted support for marriage equality, reproductive freedom and expanding Social Security and Medicare, the younger Gabbard gave every indication that she would follow in the footsteps of Mink and Hirono and join the Progressive Caucus if she were elected.

With near-universal backing of Hawaii’s progressive community, the new Tulsi was welcomed with open arms, as she trounced Hannemann in the primary and the no-name GOP candidate in the general election.

But Gabbard betrayed her liberal supporters. She never joined the Progressive Caucus. Instead, she formed the ageist Congressional Future Caucus with now-disgraced Republican Aaron Schock. And she’s compiled an F grade on Progressive Punch's rating system. She’s been a favorite guest on Fox News throughout her tenure, most frequently bashing fellow Democrats for not being sufficiently xenophobic.

Some liberals give her a pass on her record just because she backed Sanders. But Gabbard's left-leaning detractors increasingly see that endorsement as opportunistic, and they are becoming more and more vocal, from the Progress AAPI group on Facebook to journalist Sonali Kolhatkar.

Gabbard reportedly has been disinvited from this month’s People Summit, with organizers facing pressure from those who support Syrian refugees and from other activists. Critics noted she spoke at the summit last year just days after receiving >an award from GOP uber donor Sheldon Adelson. The prior summer she was the only Democrat to speak at the annual conference of the apocalyptic, Adelson-funded Christians United for Israel.

The Congressional Progressive Caucus has unveiled its most recent version of the People's Budget, its formal budget proposal, just this week. The People’s Budget has for years been regarded as a thorough, significant and coherent example of smart, compassionate public policy. And it's only gotten stronger and more popular over the years, with a majority of House Democrats voting for it in 2015.

So, it’s a good time to remember that not only has Gabbard refused to join the Progressive Caucus, she’s voted against the People’s Budget all three times it was presented to her, putting her outside the mainstream of the Democratic Party.

The founding and nurturing of the Congressional Progressive Caucus is a huge part of Bernie Sanders’ legacy. The Senate doesn’t have caucuses, but Sanders has been allowed to remain a Progressive Caucus member even after becoming a senator because it’s so important to him.

Will Gabbard have another well-timed leftward epiphany and, for the first time, support the budget put forward by Sanders’ Progressive Caucus?

Or will Gabbard maintain her perfect record of resistance to the Congressional Progressive Caucus and vote against the People’s Budget for a fourth time?

Labels: , ,

Sunday, June 19, 2016

What Does It Mean To Be A Berniecrat? Take Tulsi Gabbard

>


Trump-Gabbard '16?

Many progressives heard of Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard (D-HI) for the first time when she quit the DNC, denouncing the wicked #DebtTrapDebbie Wasserman Schultz and endorsed Bernie. If that made her a progressive in anyone's mind, it was a mistake. This week she was in the news again-- as a hold-out in endorsing Hillary-- a good progressive position on the surface... but not necessarily when you read between the lines. In many ways, she's even further right o the political scale than Hillary. (Bernie fans need to be aware of the fact that ProgressivePunch's algorithm grades Gabbard's voting record an "F," which giving Bernie an "A" (and both Hawaii's senators also "A"). An "F" isn't a "B" or even a "C." you have to be really bad, really anti-progressive, to get an "F."

A friend of mine from Capitol Hill actually floated the idea of Gabbard as a Hillary running-mate, which, at least on the surface, is patently absurd. Her record as a right-of-center Democrat wouldn't deter Hillary but does anyone really think Tulsi Gabbard, ex-girlfriend of GOP Mafioso Michael "Mikey Suits" Grimm, could pass a vetting process?

Obviously, no one on the national political scene is more of a Vladimir Putin booster and a Barack Obama detractor than Donald Trump. But Gabbard ranks a close second.

Last fall, while bizarrely invoking 9/11 as a basis for bombing Syrian civilians ("them," in her terminology), she praised Putin for his willingness to bomb and blasted Obama for his alleged unwillingness to do so.

That's strange behavior for any Democrat. But it's been working for her. Gabbard's willingness to attack Obama from the right on foreign policy has made her a darling of Fox News, which she proudly acknowledges.

  

She has spent recent days reiterating her critiques of Obama's purported dovish foreign poilcy in venues ranging from CNN (as featured on GOP.com) to the People's Summit, where she used her speech time not to advance any progressive cause, but to defend the murderous and tyrannical Assad regime.

Despite her willingness to chastise Obama, Gabbard has made it a point to avoid criticism of Trump. This is all she would say when recently pressed by the Honolulu Civil Beat: "The problem with Donald Trump is that no one really knows what Donald Trump stands for and what his polices will be if he’s elected. So, I’ll leave it at that."

Her gentle treatment of Trump, her continual attacks from the right on the Obama Administration and her admitted ambition for national prominence have led some to wonder whether she's angling for a spot on the Republican ticket or a cabinet post in the Trump Administration.

The Trump-Gabbard affinity is based on their shared Islamophobia.

She regularly uses the resources of her congressional office to promote disdain for Muslims, as seen in this press release criticizing Obama over Gitmo:

Rep. Tulsi Gabbard: Unlawful Release of Muslim Terrorist Leaders Could Endanger U.S. National Security.

Earlier this year she joined with Republicans to vote against Syrian refugees:

Gabbard supports GOP bill on Syrian refugees.

Most notably, throughout her three-year tenure in Congress, she's been the only Democrat to regularly join the Republicans and demand that Obama use the term "radical Islam" to describe terrorists:

Dem Rep. Gabbard: Use Term Radical Islamic Terrorism, "Important That You Identify Your Enemy"

Finally, in the despair and frustration after Orlando, Obama provided a strong rebuke to her, Ted Cruz and the other advocates for "magic words."

Gabbard's disdain for Muslims isn't as well known as Trump's, but is just as fierce. And it is well documented in progressive media, such as Alternet and TeleSur.

Of course, her anti-Muslim rhetoric is also being cheered on in the darkest elements of right-wing media. The conservatives who've long admired her aren't dissuaded by her well-calculated endorsement of Bernie Sanders, as seen in her recent appearance with the Adelsons.

Even her domestic politics are conservative, as has been noted here since her early days in office and more recently in Hawai`i alternative media.

So maybe a Trump-Gabbard ticket isn't such an outlandish prospect.

Gabbard has a challenger from the left in the Aug. 13 primary for Hawai'i's Second Congressional District, one of the nation's most progressive. Meet Shay Chan Hodges.

Tulsi never made it anywhere near the Bernie Congress ActBlue page; we're not crazy:
Goal Thermometer

Labels: , ,

Sunday, July 31, 2016

To Label Tulsi Gabbard A "Progressive" Is To Eviscerate The Very Meaning Of The Word And Stand It On Its Head

>

Tulsi loves Islamophobic genocidal Indian fascist Narendra Modi

I don't really know Tulsi Gabbard. When she was running for Congress in 2012 she called and asked for a Blue America endorsement. Her opponent was Mufi Hannemann, an especially contemptible conservative and a real nightmare for progressives. But Gabbard had some problems of her own. Her Republican family led the anti-gay crusade in Hawaii. Her father, a fount of homophobic psychosis is a state Senator who switched parties-- though not ideology-- so he could have more influence. I was worried about Tulsi but she sounded pretty good in our discussion, especially in regard to what I sensed to be anti-war instincts and pro-environmental instincts. I was leaning towards recommending an endorsement but when I asked her about the homophobic stance that she claims to have shed, she grew brittle and quickly ended the conversation, saying she'd call back. She never called back and Blue America never endorsed her. She beat Hannemann in the primary for the Hawaii seat that encompasses basically all of the state outside Honolulu and went on to quickly earn an "F" from ProgressivePunch. Her crucial vote score (73.46) makes her the 142nd "most progressive" Member of Congress, i.e., very much not progressive.


Before getting married in 2015, she was dating GOP Mafia thug Michael "Mikey Suits" Grimm, before he was arrested, tried and imprisoned in a case that didn't even touch on over 90% of his criminal life. Even worse, she often worked across the aisle to further the GOP agenda, joining the widely discredited Republican front organization for dummy-Dems, No Labels. And then she was righteously outraged by Debbie Wasserman Schultz's DNC cheating on behalf of Hillary and everything changed for Tulsi. She denounced Wasserman Schultz, quit the DNC and endorsed Bernie, with whom she shared almost no policy goals, other than some anti-war stands.

Tulsi's district is one of the bluest in America-- the PVI is D+21, even more Democratic than the Honolulu district. Obama won the district against McCain 73-25% and beat Romney 71-27%. There are no political reasons to amass a Republican-lite record and turn herself into an anti-Obama Fox regular. She's done it because it's who she is and it's what she believes. She may keep her homophobia under wraps, but she's released it with Islamophobia and she sounds uncomfortably more like Trump than like Bernie. Like Trump, she also been an outspoken admirer of Vladimir Putin's. In the August 13 primary she faces an actual progressive challenger, author Shay Chan Hodges. (Unfortunately, as of the June 30 FEC filing deadline, Gabbard had raised $1,361,505 and spent $558,948, while Hodges had raised $3,104 and spent $147.

Last week, Tim Mak became one of the few national journalists to give the race a look. In his post for the Daily Beast, Tulsi Gabbard: The Bernie-Endorsing Congresswoman Who Trump Fans Can Love, pointed out the absurdity of her progressive red when "her stances on standard liberal issues like gun rights and immigration are starting to converge with those of Donald J. Trump... She’s a lawmaker who has a soft spot for dictatorial regimes. She pals around with Sheldon Adelson. She’s declined to sign onto an assault weapons ban. She opposes admitting refugees. She a frequent fixture on Fox News, where she has slammed the president over his refusal to use the term “Islamic extremism” to refer to terror attacks. Sounds a lot like The Donald."
“I am little skeptical about how deep her progressive roots run,” said John Bickel, treasurer for Progressive PAC, a Hawaii state organization that endorses candidates on the left. Still, he is, at the moment, supporting Gabbard for reelection. “Tulsi Gabbard shows up in places and gets in front of the camera, spinning herself as a progressive-- but I’m not sure her record backs up what she’s created as a public persona.”

The bizarre policy overlap between Trump and Gabbard, a Bernie Sanders supporter and rising star in her party’s progressive wing, illustrates the connections between Trump and Sanders’s brands of populism. Trump is hoping to capitalize on the working-class frustration that both appeal to, with explicit calls for Sanders supporters to support his campaign, as he enters the Republican National Convention. It’s a temptation for rank-and-file Democrats that Hillary Clinton’s campaign no doubt has an eye on. Gabbard has been a favorite of Fox News, where she diverged from the typical Democratic Party line on the term “Islamic extremism.” Democrats such as Bernie Sanders-- whom Gabbard endorsed-- have stayed away from such phrases because, they argue, it suggests that the United States is at war with the Muslim religion itself.

“It is crazy,” Gabbard said on an HBO talk show, of Democratic refusals to use the term. “They do matter, words mean things, and this is what we need to look at as we look at how do we identify our enemies so that we can defeat them?”


Trump’s views on foreign policy have overthrown a generation’s worth of conservative thinking on the matter: His tolerant stance on dictators like Bashar al-Assad and Vladimir Putin shocked much of the right’s national security intelligencia. But it meshed well with Gabbard’s thinking.

In March, Gabbard was the only Democrat and one of just three members of Congress to vote against a resolution condemning violence by the Assad regime against civilian populations.

“Bad enough US has not been bombing al-Qaeda/al-Nusra in Syria. But it’s mind-boggling that we protest Russia’s bombing of these terrorists,” Gabbard wrote in September, on the first day of the Russian intervention in Syria.

Firstly, Gabbard is wrong that the U.S. has not struck al Nusra in Syria-- it has-- and secondly, her position aligns nicely with Trump’s: He called those strikes a “positive thing.” Russia is responsible for attacking U.S. backed opposition forces in Syria.

“By endorsing Bernie early and resigning from the DNC, Gabbard made clear she is vying for leadership of the next generation of left-liberals galvanized by Sanders presidential run. However, given that her and Donald Trump’s foreign and refugee policies are in lock step, real progressives should be wary of her qualification for that role,” said Evan Barrett, a political adviser to the Coalition for a Democratic Syria, a Syrian-American opposition umbrella group.

The Hawaii congresswoman was also one of just 47 Democrats who voted for a bill that would make it all but impossible to admit new refugees into the United States.

“Her vote with Republicans against admitting Syrian refugees caused a lot of heartburn here. Most of the people who are drawn towards her are sweet, gentle souls… so when they see her being heartless in that case, that is at odds of their idealization of who she is,” said a prominent Democratic activist in Hawaii. “She is the Republican right-wing’s favorite Democrat. I think both Trump and Gabbard appeal to a populist sensibility.”

And oddly enough, considering her state’s reliance on the tourism industry, she mirrored Trump’s overreach on immigration issues by calling for European passport holders to be forced to apply for tourist visas, citing terror concerns. Europeans currently have a waiver to visit the United States for leisure-- more than 143,000 European visitors traveled to Hawaii in the past year, according to the Hawaii Tourism Authority.

But foreign policy is not the only realm where Gabbard and Trump see eye to eye: She is also wishy-washy on gun control. Trump opposes a ban on assault weapons, a flip-flop from his prior positions; Gabbard, meanwhile, is conspicuously missing from Democrat efforts to legislate the issue. Eighty percent of Democrats, including fellow Hawaii Democrat Rep. Mark Takai, are co-sponsors of a bill that would ban so-called assault weapons-- Gabbard is not among them.

...When given a chance to condemn Trump, such as with this story, Gabbard avoids the topic-- and in the past, she has avoided harsh words for the Republican businessman. “One of the many problems I see with Trump is I don’t know what he believes. I don’t know what he would do,” Gabbard said in one such interview, before pivoting to criticism of Hillary Clinton. “I have raised and continue to see concerns with Hillary Clinton’s foreign policy.”

That a Democratic congresswoman from Hawaii could have so many overlapping policies with the presumptive Republican nominee for president is perplexing. But it’s yet another reminder of the unorthodox campaign season that America is now undergoing-- and the ways in which both extremes of the Republican and Democratic parties are converging in strange ways.

Labels: ,

Saturday, November 17, 2018

New Series: The Worst Democraps Who Want To Be President-- Part I, Tulsi Gabbard

>


As I mentioned a few days ago, there are a shitload of really terrible candidates jumping into the quest for the Democratic nomination for president (and vice president). Today starts a new series to introduce you to the worst of them. Tulsi Gabbard may be the worst-- or maybe the 2nd worst of 5th worst-- but I only picked her to start with because someone today told me she would never run against Bernie, which caused me try to explain the role opportunism plays in the life of careerist politicians like Tulsi. So she was fresh in my mind. And also because she plans to raise millions of dollars online from Bernie supporters before anyone realizes she's a fraud.

Before a feud with Debbie Wasserman Schultz at the DNC exploded and brought her over to Bernie’s then-struggling campaign, few people outside of Hawaii had ever heard of Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard. But once she endorsed Bernie, she became an instant hero to his grassroots army of supporters. That grassroots army that was so quick to embrace her was largely unaware of a long record of political conservativism going all the way back to her days in the Hawaii legislature where, among other things, she led the fight against LGBTQ equality and as a crusader against anti-bullying efforts. (Yes, led, which is quite different from “voted badly once or twice.”) In fact, like her mother and father, she won office primarily on anti-gay campaign messaging.

Now that she’s about to declare a bid for the presidency— a ploy to get on a ticket as vice president— it’s important to take a closer look before her p.r. people re-define her. Few people know she first won a seat on the Honolulu City Council with the backing of the Hawaii Rifle Association, the local NRA affiliate. She was a conservative who shifted left to run against another— better-known— conservative. More than a conservative or a liberal, Gabbard is, above all else, an inauthentic opportunist. One week she’s a regular Fox guest bashing Democrats for not being xenophobic enough, dating Michael “Mikey Suits” Grimm and trying to get a job in the Trump Regime… and then she’s a Berniecrat. Now she’s organizing an L.A.-based presidential campaign for herself. Will her pals the Adelsons support her? Steve Bannon?

As I warned Bernie supporters 2 years ago, ProgressivePunch's algorithm grades Gabbard's voting record an "F," while giving Bernie’s voting record an "A" (and both Hawaii's senators also "A"). An "F" isn't a "B" or even a "C." You have to be really bad, really anti-progressive, to get an “F.” No one is more of a Putin booster and a Barack Obama detractor than Señor Trumpanzee. But Gabbard was ranking a close second. A few months early, while bizarrely invoking 9/11 as a basis for bombing Syrian civilians ("them," in her terminology), she praised Putin for his willingness to bomb and blasted Obama for his alleged unwillingness to do so. That's strange behavior for any Democrat. But it was working for her. Gabbard's willingness to attack Obama from the right on foreign policy has made her a darling of Fox News, which she proudly acknowledges.

In Hawaii, she earned a reputation among her former colleagues in the State Legislature as one of their most bigoted contemporaries. She defined her local career as an outspoken anti-gay and anti-reproductive rights politician. Volumes of official records from the Hawaii State Legislative Reference Bureau tell Tulsi’s story in her own words. Here, Tulsi, then Representative Tamayo, presents a floor speech against a measure supported by local hospitals that resolved to study the needs of LGBTQ students, who suffered the highest rates of suicide in the state:




In this same speech, Tulsi is also recorded as describing gay rights advocates as “homosexual extremists.” Tulsi is no grassroots phenom. She represents the state’s main conservative political dynasty, which successfully campaigned to ban same-sex marriage through constitutional amendment. Her father, Senator Mike Gabbard, led the anti-gay movement in the state and also founded Stand Up For America, a non- profit that promoted nationalism through “the concept of how we are one nation under God.”

Tulsi was also defined by her consistent opposition to basic rights for women. Here, Tulsi joins a Republican bloc to oppose emergency contraceptives for rape victims. This was one of several instances where she attempted to restrict reproductive rights for women on the grounds of religious freedom.




In 2016 she used her speech at the People’s Summit not to advance anything to do with a progressive agenda, but to advance any progressive cause, but to defend the murderous and tyrannical Assad regime. At the time, people started noticing that despite her willingness to chastise Obama, she was making it a point to avoid criticism of Trump. This is all she would say when pressed by the Honolulu Civil Beat: "The problem with Donald Trump is that no one really knows what Donald Trump stands for and what his polices will be if he’s elected. So, I’ll leave it at that."

Her gentle treatment of Trump, her attacks from the right on the Obama Administration and her admitted ambition for national prominence led some to wonder whether she was angling for a spot on the Republican ticket or a cabinet post in the Trump Administration. At the time, the Trump-Gabbard affinity was based on their shared Islamophobia. And a shared admiration for Steve Bannon. She joined with Republicans to vote against Syrian refugees. She was regularly using the resources of her congressional office to promote disdain for Muslims.



John Bickel, treasurer for Progressive PAC, a Hawaii state organization that endorses candidates on the left, doesn’t trust her and sees the gross opportunism shining through. “Tulsi Gabbard shows up in places and gets in front of the camera, spinning herself as a progressive-- but I’m not sure her record backs up what she’s created as a public persona. I am little skeptical about how deep her progressive roots run.”

Long before her sudden transformation into a Berniecrat, Gabbard called me to ask for a Blue America endorsement. She didn't really try to paint herself as a progressive and, other than sounding good on the environment, she came across as a garden variety careerist Democrat, not especially bad and not especially good. At the end of the interview, I asked her about the process by which she had come to change her position on LGBT equality. She immediately said she'd call back and then hung up abruptly and... never called back. And we never endorsed her.


Labels: , , , , ,