
I hope you watched
the video of Maxine Waters talking about the health care battle that we ran last night. In it she answered a question from MSNBC anchor Carlos Watson about primarying Blue Dogs and conservative Democrats. Her response was that "you can't make empty threats... But many of these Blue Dogs," she continued, "represent districts that have strong pockets of poverty and minorities and they're not representing them with this approach that they're taking. I don't know whether or not there will be people running against them. Certainly we're [the House Progressive Caucus] not organized to run anybody against anybody. That's not normally what's done. But there may be people out there listening and observing all of this who may get motivated based on what they're seeing and throw their hat into the ring." This morning
The Hill reported that she
warned Blue Dogs to beware 2010.
I doubt many of them are frightened (although the Blue Dogs bolded in the chart below could be made to be frightened). Of the 51 Blue Dogs, only 19 represent districts that Obama won in 2008. Most of those 19 are not among the really outright reactionary neo-Confederates and Republican-oriented, anti-family Blue Dogs making all the trouble, your Mike Rosses, Baron Hills and Heath Shulers. Most but not all. Below is a list of all the Blue Dogs, starting with their 4 right-wing leaders, that shows which presidential candidate won each of their districts in 2008:
• Rep. Stephanie Herseth Sandlin (SD)- McCain 53%
• Rep. Baron Hill (IN)- McCain 50%
• Rep. Charlie Melancon (LA)- McCain 61%
• Rep. Heath Shuler (NC)- McCain 52%
• Rep. Jason Altmire (PA)- McCain 55%
• Rep. Mike Arcuri (NY)- Obama 51%
• Rep. Joe Baca (CA)- Obama 68%
• Rep. John Barrow (GA)- Obama 54%
• Rep. Marion Berry (AR)- McCain 59%
• Rep. Sanford Bishop (GA)- Obama 54%
• Rep. Dan Boren (OK)- McCain 66%
• Rep. Leonard Boswell (IA)- Obama 54%
• Rep. Allen Boyd (FL)- McCain 54%
• Rep. Bobby Bright (AL)- McCain 63%
• Rep. Dennis Cardoza (CA)- Obama 59%
• Rep. Chris Carney (PA)- McCain 54%
• Rep. Ben Chandler (KY)- McCain 55%
• Rep. Travis Childers (MS)- McCain 62%
• Rep. Jim Cooper (TN)- Obama 56%
• Rep. Jim Costa (CA)- Obama 60%
• Rep. Henry Cuellar (TX)- Obama 56%
• Rep. Lincoln Davis (TN)- McCain 64%
• Rep. Joe Donnelly (IN)- Obama 54%
• Rep. Brad Ellsworth (IN)- McCain 51%
• Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (AZ)- McCain 52%
• Rep. Bart Gordon (TN)- McCain 62%
• Rep. Parker Griffith (AL)- McCain 61%
• Rep. Jane Harman (CA)- Obama 64%
• Rep. Tim Holden (PA)- McCain 51%
• Rep. Frank Kratovil, Jr. (MD)- McCain 58%
• Rep. Mike McIntyre (NC)- McCain 52%
• Rep. Jim Marshall (GA)- McCain 56%
• Rep. Jim Matheson (UT)- McCain 57%
• Rep. Mike Michaud (ME)- Obama 55%
• Rep. Walt Minnick (ID)- McCain 62%
• Rep. Harry Mitchell (AZ)- McCain 52%
• Rep. Dennis Moore (KS)- Obama 51%
• Rep. Patrick Murphy (PA)- Obama 54%
• Rep. Glenn Nye (VA)- Obama 51%
• Rep. Collin Peterson (MN)- McCain 50%
• Rep. Earl Pomeroy (ND)- McCain 53%
• Rep. Mike Ross (AR)- McCain 58%
• Rep. John Salazar (CO)- McCain 50%
• Rep. Loretta Sanchez (CA)- Obama 60%
• Rep. Adam Schiff (CA)- Obama 68%
• Rep. David Scott (GA)- Obama 71%
• Rep. Zack Space (OH)- McCain 52%
• Rep. John Tanner (TN)- McCain 56%
• Rep. Gene Taylor (MS)- McCain 68%
• Rep. Mike Thompson (CA)- Obama 66%
• Rep. Charles Wilson (OH)- McCain 50%
Last year, two of the really bad Blue Dogs, Nick Lampson (TX) and Don Cazayoux (LA), were defeated but they were defeated by very far right Republicans. Lampson had disillusioned enough local progressives so that they just didn't vote for him-- he got a mere 45% of the vote, a crushing defeat for an incumbent-- and one who had basically spent two years voting like a Republican. Cazayoux was similar story. He had been elected in a special election by promising to be a representative for working families, including inner city working families in Baton Rouge. The Baton Rouge inner city precincts
put him over the top and no one could possibly say otherwise. But as soon as he got to Congress, he started ignoring his own constituents, cultivating Big Business lobbyists and his district's Republicans (i.e.- the Blue Dog model). It was his (well-deserved) misfortune that a Democratic Baton Rouge state senator,
Michael Jackson, jumped into the race as a third party, candidate and sealed Cazayoux's fate.
Now, let's look at 2010 and what
The Hill claims to be Maxine's threats. Most of the worst Blue Dogs-- the most consistent aisle crossers-- are in hopelessly red districts with huge Republican majorities. Most of the ones
making the most trouble over health care reform are in backward, reactionary districts where Rush Limbaugh and Pat Robertson are the primary sources of conventional wisdom. These are the voters who believe Obama was born in Mecca or Kenya or Mexico and that the health care bill would mean
euthanasia for granny. The most that could be hoped for by pouring resources into races against Gene Taylor, Dan Boren, Chris Carney, Bobby Bright, Jim Marshall and Travis Childers-- the worst of the worst-- would be replacing them with even worse Republicans (which is what happened in Louisiana and Texas), not such terrible outcomes, since at least their excisions would prevent a further deterioration of the damaged and confusing Democratic brand and a further drift inside the Democratic Party away from representing the interests of working families and progressive values. But it is hardly a goal many Democrats-- other than some
Blue America donors-- will embrace. (I fully embrace the idea myself, in case you're new to the site.)
On the other hand, many of the housebroken Blue Dogs are from heavily Democratic districts and have modified their reactionary orientations to better reflect their constituents demands. When the Blue Dog leaders brag that they have 51 votes to cross the aisle and kill the public option, they're not telling the truth. Mike Michaud, Patrick Murphy, Adam Schiff, Sanford Bishop, Mike Thompson-- to name a few-- are not going to vote with the Republicans against the public option.
That leaves us with a few vulnerable Blue Dogs who are bad players and who
can be taken out in primaries: John Barrow (who, ironically, Obama saved from political oblivion last year), Insurance Industry shill/anti-reform fanatic Jim Cooper (whose Nashville district sounds exactly like what Maxine was talking about), Henry Cuellar, Leonard Boswell, Joe Donnelly (the worst cross-over artist among Democrats in the House), and Jane Harman, who has a very serious challenge from local progressive heroine Marcy Winograd.
Let's keep in mind that last month, a
NY Times/CBS poll reported that the GOP’s favorability ratings have sunk to an astounding record-breaking low-- 28%, down from a high of 59% in November 1994. Republican Party voter registration numbers are in the toilet. If voters view GOP obstructionism as adding to the country's problems-- the way they did after Roosevelt was elected to fix the economy that runaway Republican policies under Harding, Coolidge and Hoover had wrecked-- there is no reason why we won't see double digit GOP losses in the House and at least 5 or 6 Senate seat changes from red to blue. However, more bad Democrats is not going to solve anyone's problems.
It wouldn't bother me one bit if state Sen. Alan Nunnelee (KKK-MS) takes out one of the most reactionary of the Blue Dogs, Travis Childers but it's incumbent on progressive activists to get involved now-- the way Blue Dogs do-- to recruit and support progressive Democrats. One of the best examples is in the Florida district that Adam Putnam is abandoning where Blue Dogs are strongly supporting-- with cash-- an anti-health care conservative, Lori Edwards, while
progressives are rallying around progressive navy vet Doug Tudor. If you'd like to donate to Doug's campaign, you can do it
here through Act Blue.
It's important to get in early on races like Doug's because if we don't, we'll be presented with a
fait accompli by either the Blue Dogs or the DCCC (or, as is often the case, the two groups working in concert). And speaking of Doug, there's another Doug I want to call your attention to, Doug Pike, the progressive candidate running for the open seat in the Philly 'burbs being abandoned by Jim Gerlach. His potential opponent is a sleazy reactionary state senator, Andy Dinniman, who brags that his values dictate that he
vote with the Republicans more than with the Democrats (60/40 by his own estimate). Just what we need-- and, of course, a perfect Blue Dog candidate. I suspect Dinniman's values wouldn't allow him to send out an e-mail like the one I got today from Doug Pike:
Right now, in compliance with the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" law (DADT), the United States military is firing good soldiers-- simply for being gay, lesbian or bisexual. This policy is wrong, and it makes our nation less safe.
I reject the argument that the U.S. military can't function effectively with gay men and women serving openly. Many of our allies allow gay men and women to serve openly in their militaries, and no
one would ever accuse these militaries-- the Israel Defense Forces or the British Army-- of lacking toughness or suffering from morale problems.
I also don’t accept the argument that the men and women in the U.S. armed forces lack the professionalism to work alongside servicemembers who are gay. We have the greatest military in the world, and they are ready to do their jobs without this outdated policy causing them to lose capable comrades-in-arms for no good reason. We’re fighting two wars, and we need all hands on deck.
What’s more, over 100 retired generals and admirals agree. They recently signed a letter urging Congress to repeal DADT.
I endorse the Military Readiness Enhancement Act (H.R. 1283), which would replace DADT with a policy of non-discrimination, allowing gay individuals to serve openly in the U.S. Armed Forces.
...It is past time to repeal this policy. A recent Washington Post/ABC News poll showed that 75% of all Americans-- and 59% of Republicans-- believe gays and lesbians should be able to serve openly in the military.
Moreover, the DADT law is a huge waste of our nation's time and resources at a moment when we are facing a financial crisis. According to a 2005 GAO study, American taxpayers paid at least $250 million and possibly much more to replace servicemembers under DADT.
That sense of fairness and resolve is what we should expect to hear from Democratic candidates, not mealy mouthed conservatism seeking to preserve the status quo. Real leaders-- like Doug Tudor and Doug Pike-- lead. Only 15 Democrats opposed the Matthew Shepard Hate Crimes Bill-- and every single one of them was a Blue Dog cur. They're not Democrats; they're conservatives, using the Democratic Party for their own career advancement.
Labels: Blue Dogs, Doug Pike, Maxine Waters, reactionary Democrats